Connect with us

Uncategorized

A Naturalist explains why Game of Thrones ecology can't exist in real world

Published

on

The thing about fiction and its fans are that most of us hope, at one point or the other, that it were all real. When it comes to Game of Thrones, we are not sure how many of us would want to experience that reality, but it wouldn’t hurt to imagine. Then there are some among us who go a step further and logically reason out if such a world could actually exist, gives the current set of rules that existence obeys. Naturalish is one such blog, where fantasy, science fiction, and myths are dissected under the lens of science, to find out if they are realistically possible. In the latest post by the blog, Game of Thrones got the treatment, and it seems that the ecology shown in the show is impossible. Read on!

Naturalish, going on the popular blogging platform, Medium, posts some really eye-opening content in this niche, and its analysis of Game of Thrones matches up. Now, one doesn’t need a deep knowledge of biology to understand this, but the prime argument made in the post says that there are simply can’t be way too many wild creatures, in space that is way too small. Naturalish explains :

“Put bluntly: Westeros packs too many similar species into too small of a landmass.” 

It continues :

“To simplify this article and avoid compiling an entire encyclopedia of Westerosi wildlife (which of course already exists) I’ll be focusing exclusively on apex predators. These different species all fit approximately into the same ecological niche, and assuming wildlife in Westeros follow the same basic principles as they do in our world, these animals would compete over similar resources — mainly large herbivorous prey. Yum.

This also conveniently reduces our list to just six species of note: bears, wolves, direwolves, shadowcats, lions, and lizard-lions (which are basically alligators but I guess the Maesters were feeling extra creative that day).”

The post provides a (not to scale) map to show the fallacy in wildlife distribution that author George R. R. Martin commits. Check it below :

Naturalish argues that the landmass of Westeros is not only too small to allow for the ecology, it also has a lot of disturbances that would further make it impossible for such a distribution to exist the way it is shown to exist, with unlikely species overlapping.

“The size of Westeros, actually, doesn’t require the same degree of estimation — luckily that’s been calculated to great detail already. The landmass is tall and narrow, but from the Wall to the lower tip of Dorne the estimates all converge around 3000 miles, and for context that’s approximately the distance from coast-to-coast in the USA. This is a nice “goldilocks” zone for land size: big enough that we should expect species diversity, but small enough that this diversity (in theory) would lead to competitive exclusion.”

Another graphic to show the disturbances in geography :

..and explanation as to why that makes the ecology even harder to exist realistically :

“There are some significant bottlenecks, like the Wall or the Neck (a swampy river region that’s a challenge to traverse), but few other geographic formations actually cut off large swathes of land.

This makes it clear that there isn’t quite enough geographic variation to, say, convince me that lions and wolves deviated from a common ancestor. We would expect variation between the North and South, but there’s hardly enough to account for so many diverse and overlapping species that occupy the same space.”

The post has much more to be read, and Naturalish goes into enough detail to convince you of their opinion, so head on here to read it. Come back to talk to us, in the comments down below!

(4058)

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Wiki Of Thrones: Final Destination for Game of Thrones News

Published

on

By

  • cersei-and-jamie-on-the-iron-throne-400x240-9563379 cersei-and-jamie-on-the-iron-throne-80x80-6360651News2 days ago

    Game of Thrones during its run changed lives around the globe. Not only did it turn out to be a profitable venture for all involved it…

  • kit-harington-eternals-1-400x240-1757730 kit-harington-eternals-1-80x80-6794132Interview2 days ago

    Game of Thrones and the Marvel Cinematic Universe, both share a few similarities, such as the profound secrecy involved in their filming, as well as sharing a number…

  • 2ew2t6q-matt-smith-wallpaper-400x240-7391667 2ew2t6q-matt-smith-wallpaper-80x80-4810576Interview4 days ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is fast on track for its release in 2022. The production hit a little snag recently after a positive COVID-19 case was…

  • miguel-sapochnik-400x240-1029855 miguel-sapochnik-80x80-4109777Interview4 days ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is one of the high-priority projects at HBO currently underway. The production is moving swiftly despite hitting some minor obstacles along…

  • jennifer-ehle-400x240-3913574 jennifer-ehle-80x80-8299626Interview4 days ago

    When Game of Thrones first started filming, it was a jumbling mess. The original pilot was so bad, it had to be refilmed. Back then, no…

  • game-of-thrones-ed-sheeran-arya-400x240-3274763 game-of-thrones-ed-sheeran-arya-80x80-5711048Humour5 days ago

    Ed Sheeran made an appearance on Game of Thrones during the Season 7 premiere and it soon turned into a nightmare for him as many fans of the show…

  • bryan-cox-1-400x240-3056230 bryan-cox-1-80x80-2610874Interview5 days ago

    Game of Thrones is one of the biggest shows of the 21st century, and even though the show’s ending didn’t please all its fans, the cast…

  • momoa-dune-trailer01_wide-400x240-1125900 momoa-dune-trailer01_wide-80x80-9539506Humour5 days ago

    Dune is one of the most successful sci-fi movies of this year, and if successful we might be looking at one of the best fantasy-based movie…

  • house-of-the-dragon-400x240-6699081 house-of-the-dragon-80x80-3780633General7 days ago

    The production for Game of Thrones prequel House of the Dragon is in full swing. We’re receiving updates about the filming currently going on in the Portuguese city of stone, Monsanto,…

  • jon-snow-400x240-5613196 jon-snow-80x80-6925422News7 days ago

    Game of Thrones had a massive impact on the fantasy genre, playing into several myths and legends inside its universe. Blood was shed, kings were crowned…

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

General Archives – Page 3 of 205 – Wiki of Thrones

Published

on

By

  • george-r-r-martin-calls-elden-ring-a-sequel-to-dark-souls-400x240-3902735 george-r-r-martin-calls-elden-ring-a-sequel-to-dark-souls-80x80-2490876General3 months ago

    It has been over a decade since the last Game of Thrones book was released. Fans have been waiting impatiently for George R. R. Martin to…

  • emilia-400x240-6690944 emilia-80x80-2481044General3 months ago

    Game of Thrones star Iain Glen has finally decided to join the social media platform Instagram. Guess who is the first one to welcome him? His…

  • got-5-400x240-3460028 got-5-80x80-4172088General3 months ago

    Video games and TV shows/movies have often worked hand-in-hand to help promote each other. They also provide the ultimate user experience, where players can live through…

  • General3 months ago

    Game of Thrones wrapped up filming nearly two years ago, but it has been a decade since the most recent book in the series came out….

  • fb_img_16202280766709022-400x240-6021730 fb_img_16202280766709022-80x80-6860744General3 months ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is fast on track for its release in 2022. The production hit a little snag recently after a…

  • wp4335278-george-r-r-martin-wallpapers-400x240-5193127 wp4335278-george-r-r-martin-wallpapers-80x80-6265707General3 months ago

    The Iron Throne has become a pop culture icon and a symbol of power in the fictional world. It represents an absolute reign, that corrupted many…

  • got-1-400x240-4712935 got-1-80x80-4533084General3 months ago

    There’s hardly any doubt that some props from Game of Thrones have turned into pop culture icons. The one that stands out amongst them is the…

  • sub-buzz-7980-1626134653-12-400x240-6344161 sub-buzz-7980-1626134653-12-80x80-4601189General3 months ago

    Game of Thrones slot machines have been in news recently, especially after Kit Harington’s reaction video going viral. However, not everyone can go to the Sin…

  • sei_81479208-400x240-2372919 sei_81479208-80x80-6508168General4 months ago

    Game of Thrones merchandise is very rare to get your hands on, a prop from the TV show is even rarer. The cast members were themselves…

  • red-wedding-400x240-2976023 red-wedding-80x80-8686867General4 months ago

    The Red Wedding remains one of the most horrifying and gruesome episodes in Game of Thrones history. The inspiration for the loathsome butchering of Rob Stark,…

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

News Archives – Page 3 of 53 – Wiki of Thrones

Published

on

By

  • house-dragon_aw5lrwdmbw4-400x240-2789274 house-dragon_aw5lrwdmbw4-80x80-3253614News4 weeks ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is moving fast with its production, and we can expect a spring release in 2022. Most of the…

  • house-of-the-dragon-400x240-8970791 house-of-the-dragon-80x80-9953648News4 weeks ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is moving quite swiftly with its production, as evident from the frequent leaks we are witnessing every other…

  • game-of-thrones-prequel-house-of-the-dragon-might-arrive-sooner-than-expected-400x240-5851364 game-of-thrones-prequel-house-of-the-dragon-might-arrive-sooner-than-expected-80x80-7964128News4 weeks ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is moving fast with its production, and we can expect a spring release in 2022. Most of the…

  • night-king-400x240-2560291 night-king-80x80-4336993News4 weeks ago

    Video games and TV shows/movies have often worked hand-in-hand to help promote each other. They also provide the ultimate user experience, where players can live through…

  • matt-smith-3-400x240-7108092 matt-smith-3-80x80-2676150News1 month ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is one of the high priority projects at HBO currently. The production is moving swiftly despite hitting some…

  • e0brpl0wyauhvpy-400x240-2558289 e0brpl0wyauhvpy-80x80-4716063News1 month ago

    The production for Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is moving rather swiftly, and we might see George R. R. Martin’s prediction about the…

  • monsanto-1-400x240-1489934 monsanto-1-80x80-5216649News1 month ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is currently one of the top priority projects at HBO. The cast and the crew were recently spotted…

  • monsanto-400x240-1221469 monsanto-80x80-7989590News1 month ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is on the roll with its production, and we can expect the series to be here in early…

  • game-of-thrones-prequel-house-of-the-dragon-might-arrive-sooner-than-expected-400x240-5851364 game-of-thrones-prequel-house-of-the-dragon-might-arrive-sooner-than-expected-80x80-7964128News1 month ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is moving steadily with its production, and we can expect the series to be here not too far…

  • matt-smith-house-of-the-dragon-400x240-1120994 matt-smith-house-of-the-dragon-80x80-5955428News1 month ago

    Game of Thrones prequel House of The Dragon is scheduled to be released in early 2022, and it seems they are going to make it in…

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2017 Zox News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by WordPress.